I attempted 3 store-bought rotisserie chickens and Costco’s well-known hen could not examine to the perfect one


Bird's eye view of three rotisserie chickens lined up on a white table. Arrows and text pointing to each chicken, from left to right read, "Whole Foods," "Costco," and "Safeway"

I in contrast three rotisserie chickens from Complete Meals, Costco, and Safeway.Chelsea Davis

  • I in contrast three rotisserie chickens from Costco, Safeway, and Complete Meals.

  • The hen from Complete Meals was dry and never juicy in any respect, so I wasn’t impressed with this one.

  • Safeway’s rotisserie hen was my favourite as a result of it was merely scrumptious and completely tender.

I discover it tremendous handy to choose up a rotisserie hen on the grocery retailer, however I needed to seek out out which was the perfect.

The writer holds the Costco rotisserie chicken. Liquid can be seen at the bottom of the plastic container the chicken sits in

I used to be excited to strive Costco’s hen, which was the biggest.Chelsea Davis

Shopping for a scorching, juicy rotisserie hen is sort of at all times a good suggestion as a result of it is comparatively wholesome, normally low-cost, and tremendous handy for when you do not need to prepare dinner.

I attempted three rotisserie chickens from Costco, Complete Meals, and Safeway to seek out out which hen tasted the perfect total.

I took a pattern from the leg, breast, and thigh for probably the most thorough comparability.

I began with the 3-pound behemoth from Costco.

Large whole rotisserie chicken in a black container on a white table

This rotisserie hen was huge.Chelsea Davis

The sheer dimension of this rotisserie hen was fairly astounding in comparison with the opposite birds. That stated, Costco’s 3-pound hen was fairly a steal at solely $4.99.

Costco’s rotisserie hen can also be the perfect deal out of the bunch.

The reasonably priced hen is such an enormous hit with clients that, in 2015, Costco’s chief monetary advisor Wealthy Galanti reportedly stated they have been prepared to lose “$30 to $40 million a yr in gross margin” on the birds by promoting them for underneath $5.

Nonetheless, I used to be skeptical of a few of the components.

A Costco rotisserie chicken sits on a white table with Kirkland label in front

The label stated there have been no added hormones or steroids to the Costco hen.Chelsea Davis

The opposite chickens I attempted had only a few recognizable components like salt, pepper, and herbs, however this one listed issues I hadn’t heard of, like sodium phosphate and modified meals starch.

However in keeping with Mashed, sodium phosphate is an additive that helps hold meats moist and maintains freshness, and modified meals starch is usually used for thickening, stabilizing, or emulsifying.

After a fast web search, I realized these birds are injected with a particular saline resolution so as to add taste, which may additionally clarify the presence of these components.

That stated, the hen tasted fairly good.

The writer holds a piece of leg meat from Costco rotisserie chicken

The meat itself was tender and engaging.Chelsea Davis

Placing apart my skepticism concerning the components within the Costco hen, the meat was seasoned nicely.

The leg wasn’t extremely moist and slightly on the dry facet, but it surely was nonetheless good. The thigh, which is at all times my favourite a part of the hen, was very juicy and tender.

The breast wasn’t as juicy and moist, however nonetheless satisfying contemplating that this a part of the hen tends to be on the drier facet. It was dense and had a very good mouthfeel to it.

There was one thing bizarre occurring with the pores and skin.

The writer holds a piece of chicken breast with a layer of fat underneath skin

I observed a second layer of what seemed to be fats on the Costco hen.Chelsea Davis

Although the golden-brown exterior of the hen was tasty, I observed that there gave the impression to be a second layer of pores and skin on the hen. I am not precisely positive what this was, but it surely did not style excellent.

This layer between the golden-brown layer and the precise meat was virtually like a fats deposit and was extremely off-putting.

The opposite two chickens did not have this whitish layer on them. Possibly I simply received a dud — I have not seen different folks speaking about this problem earlier than — however nonetheless, this layer of pores and skin made the consuming expertise much less pleasing.

General, the Costco hen was tasty, however not fairly proper.

The writer holds a piece of Costco chicken breast meat; The writer holds a clump of Costco chicken thigh meat

Costco’s hen was OK, however the worth was unbeatable.Chelsea Davis

The meat itself, notably the thigh, was positively moist however in an oily, overly moist type of manner. This hen additionally leaked extra further juices to the underside of the container than any of the opposite birds.

Value-wise, the Costco hen won’t ever be crushed. Nonetheless, taste- and texture-wise, it wasn’t the best possible rotisserie hen I’ve had. I felt that its taste appeared unnatural.

Nonetheless, I would positively eat it once more in a pinch.

I attempted the Complete Meals hen subsequent.

A rotisserie chicken sits in a bag with clear and green plastic. The legs of the chicken are tied together

This was such a tragic hen.Chelsea Davis

There was actually nothing tremendous interesting concerning the $10.99 Complete Meals rotisserie hen aside from the truth that it was made with easy components.

First off, it got here in a bag with no juices and it regarded shriveled up.

I used to be glad to see that the hen was made with recognizable components.

Rotisserie chicken in a clear and green plastic bag with Whole Foods label on outside and visible ingredient list

I knew what every ingredient listed on the Complete Meals hen was.Chelsea Davis

In line with the label, this Complete Meals hen was raised with out antibiotics or added hormones and the components have been clear: natural hen and pepper and salt.

Nonetheless, there weren’t many issues I preferred about this hen.

The writer holds a piece of Whole Foods chicken breast meat; The writer holds a chicken thigh with seasoning on it

Complete Meals’ hen was mediocre at greatest.Chelsea Davis

The hen was dry and even the darkish meat tasted overcooked. A minimum of the pores and skin was crisp and the seasoning, which was simply salt and pepper, was acceptable and satisfying.

That stated, for the value, I’d have anticipated the next high quality hen.

This was a tragic, overcooked hen that lacked moisture, but it surely did style prefer it was most likely good for me.

Lastly, I moved on to Safeway’s hen.

A rotisserie chicken sits in a black container on a white counter

Safeway’s rotisserie hen had a balanced taste.Chelsea Davis

This hen was scrumptious. It was the perfect of each Costco’s and Complete Meals’ chickens.

This hen was reasonably priced at $8.99 and a manageable dimension for a rotisserie hen at underneath 2 kilos. The components made sense: hen rubbed with salt, paprika, sugar, turmeric, onion and garlic powder, and pure smoke taste.

The meat was juicy and tender all through the hen.

The meat was barely oily and really juicy.

The writer holds a piece of Safeway chicken breast; The writer holds a piece of Safeway chicken thigh

The meat on Safeway’s hen was tremendous moist.Chelsea Davis

The meat was tremendous juicy, moist, and ever so oily. It tasted actually good and the pores and skin’s seasoning was by far my favourite out of the three chickens. I additionally preferred the slight smokiness and the sweetness mixed with the reasonably salty meat.

The darkish meat was tremendous moist and never stringy and the thigh pulled aside prefer it ought to — not in strings or globs like with the Costco hen.

The breast meat was moist and had the tender density that I would count on from this a part of the hen.

General, Safeway’s hen was my favourite.

Three rotisserie chickens lined up on a white table. The right most chicken has a red arrow and "Winner" text pointing to it

Safeway’s rotisserie hen had the perfect pores and skin, texture, and style.Chelsea Davis

If I need one other rotisserie hen, I’ll Safeway. The pores and skin was so tasty that I ended up wrapping items of it round my hen bites. I additionally grew up consuming this rotisserie hen and now it is smart why.

The darkish meat was tender and moist, with out the unusual wetness that was current in some elements of the Costco hen. I preferred that I might acknowledge every ingredient on the record for the Safeway hen as nicely.

The meat has the feel a hen ought to have — not stringy or spongy — with darkish meat that is appropriately dense and tender.

Learn the unique article on Insider

Comments are closed.